Songs get the attention. The score — the instrumental music running underneath dialogue and action — does most of the emotional work and receives almost none of the credit, partly because it is designed not to be noticed.
Score tells you how to feel before you know why
A scene of two people talking in a room is neutral information. The score decides whether you experience it as tender, threatening or sad, and it makes that decision several seconds before the dialogue confirms it. This is why a badly scored film feels wrong in a way audiences struggle to articulate — the music has been telling them something the scene then contradicts.
Three things to listen for
Where it starts and stops. The entry point of a cue is a directorial decision. Music arriving early tells you a moment matters before the actors do; arriving late lets a moment land on its own first. Silence where you expected music is one of the strongest tools available, and its absence in a film usually means nobody was making choices.
Whether themes recur. A theme attached to a character or idea, returning in altered form, is doing narrative work — it can tell you a relationship has changed without a word of dialogue. Scores without recurring material are usually assembled rather than composed.
What instruments carry emotion. Punjabi cinema has a deep traditional palette — tumbi, algoza, dhol, sarangi — and how a film deploys it against orchestral or electronic textures is a statement about what the film thinks it is. A film that reaches for strings in every emotional moment and traditional instruments only for celebration is telling you something about its own idea of the culture it depicts.
The budget problem
Score is expensive and invisible, which makes it the easiest thing to cut. Many Punjabi features arrive with libraries of stock cues rather than composed music, and the effect is a film that feels generic even when its images are specific.
This is worth naming in criticism, because it is a fixable problem that goes unremarked. A film with a modest but genuinely composed score will outperform a better-funded film using library music, and audiences feel the difference without being able to name it.
An exercise
Rewatch a scene you found moving with the sound off. Then again with sound. Most of what you attributed to the performance was probably the music.
Comments 0